Skip to content

Project 5-Year Total Cost of Ownership Across Candidate Cars

Look beyond sticker price and MPG to tally real 5-year depreciation, loan interest, insurance, state property/tab fees, tires, and scheduled repairs.

Copy the prompt and paste it into the AI assistant you already use.

The six cost buckets that determine what a car actually costs

  1. 01

    Depreciation is almost always #1 (35%–50% of TCO)

    Purchase price minus realistic 5-year wholesale trade-in value dwarfs a 4-mpg fuel difference; losing 55% vs 38% on a $36,000 vehicle is an invisible $6,120 swing.

  2. 02

    Financing interest & sales-tax base

    Higher sticker price multiplies state sales tax (6%–10%) plus 60-month loan interest, and used-car loans routinely carry 1.5%–2.5% higher APRs than subsidized new-car notes.

  3. 03

    VIN-specific insurance + state ad-valorem renewals

    Two $32,000 cars can differ by $700/year in collision premiums ($3,500 over 5 years), and states with value-based annual property/excise taxes penalize higher MSRPs yearly.

  4. 04

    Consumables schedule (tires, brakes, fluids) at 45k–60k

    Heavy EVs and 20-inch SUV wheels burn through $1,200 tire sets in 30k–38k miles, whereas 17-inch commuter sedans stretch $680 tire sets past 55,000 miles.

Common questions

Why did narrowing the new-vs-used price gap flip the TCO math on popular models?

When 2-to-3-year-old reliable crossovers sell for just 12%–15% below brand-new MSRP, higher used-loan APRs, lost bumper-to-bumper warranty, and imminent $1,600 tire/brake jobs often make new cheaper per mile.

How much fuel difference does it really take to justify a $3,500 hybrid upgrade?

At 12,000 miles/year and $3.50/gal gas, jumping from 30 mpg ($1,400/yr) to 46 mpg ($913/yr) saves $487/year ($2,435 in 5 years)—so the rest of the payback comes from higher hybrid resale value.

What per-mile all-in cost is realistic for a modern mainstream car?

Accounting for depreciation, interest, insurance, fuel, registration, and maintenance at 15,000 miles/year, compact cars average ~$0.52–$0.62/mile while midsize SUVs and trucks run ~$0.72–$0.95/mile.

Learn more

Related guides and background articles for this task